Josh Malerman
Del Rey
April 10, 2018
5 stars
Anyone who reads my review knows that I am heads over heels in love with
the novels of Josh Malerman. You must believe me when I say I am not
being paid to say that. He is that good. His first novel was
Bird Box which is the type of horror novel veteran writers would give their non-dominant arm for. The second novel,
Mad Black Wheel, is just as good. Now we have his third novel,
Unbury Carol and, for reasons to be related soon, it is the most unusual of the three and the most exciting in many ways.
Carol
Evers has a very rare condition. She can elapse into a coma at any time
which can persist from 2 days to a week. it is so deep that even
doctors mistake it for death. The only people alive who know about the
condition is her ex-lover outlaw James Moxie and her husband Dwight
Evers. When Carol falls into her coma this time, Dwight is prepared to
tell all that Carol is dead. He intends to bury her alive in what he
sees as the perfect murder. it is up to James to ride to her rescue, a
task that will not be made easy since an arson loving hit man is also on
his trail.
Unbury Carol is a departure for the author in
several ways. Like his last two books, it has clear aspects of horror
especially in the segments that depicts Carol's dream-like coma and some
vague supernatural aspects. What is perceived as magic and what isn't
is a regular theme in the book. But it also threads finely between
horror, western, and suspense. The world depicted in the novel is very
much that of a Wild West environment and the era of the late 19th
century. Yet it isn't really stated as such. The region is essentially a
closed system independent of any known references, consisting of two
main towns, Carol's Harrows and James' Mackatoon, connected by a route
simply known as the Trail. The rest of the towns on the Trail are little
more than watering holes and traps of temptations for the traveler.
There is a Pilgrim's Progress sense of allegory here. James Moxie is a
lost soul haunted by his decision to leave Carol due to her illness. The
Trail is his pilgrimage to save Carol and redeem himself. James find
both villains and allies on this path but it is Smoke, one of the most
evil bad guys I've read about in ages, that dominates the horror of the
chase. While James races to get to Carol in time her husband, who is
pretty despicable in his own way, attempts to fulfill his "perfect
murder" plot despite a mortician and a lawman who senses something isn't
right.
On top of all this, we also get an account of Carol's
residence in her coma which she calls Howltown. These are the most
horrific segments in the novel and probably the segments that will scare
most people. Being caught in a coma is terrifying enough but to know
you have full conscience and helplessly waiting to wake up six feet
under is the stuff most people would rather not think about. Carol's
Howltown though, has its own dreads to pile on top of Carol's very real
fear of premature burial.
Under a less skillful writer, and
presuming it was written as a straight Western genre novel, it still
would have been an intriguing idea. But there is something about
Malerman's setting and how he employs it that sends it into pure wonder.
The author's Wild West world is a fantasy world of his own. There is no
real life references to where it is or even to the actual time frame.
Most of the action in the novel could be explained by our real world
environment but there are hints and actions that tip us off to that not
being the case. This hedging of realities gives this novel an uniqueness
that I believe most writers would have trouble pulling off. Malerman
doesn't just pull it off but shoots it with all barrels out of the park.
The other great strength of the book is its characters. The four main
character, being Carol, Dwight, James, and Smoke are also incredibly
strong and three dimensional. But even the more minor players such as
Sheriff Opal, The mortician Manders and an especially hyper but
marginally moral Rinaldo becomes essential in this impossible to put
down fable.
I use "allegory" and "fable" intentionally for this is
what really stays with me. It's about correcting past mistakes and
redeeming ones' self and the consequences of ignoring both. It is based
on a vaguely familiar world but filled with the type of actions similar
to those we have made, regretted and wish to amend. it is also filled
with those less admirable character who made evil decisions and are
unable or unwilling to recognize them or correct them.
Unbury Carol
works on so many levels it's almost ridiculous. it can be scary as
hell, It is a story of love and redemption, and it is a vastly
entertaining western action saga. And this is where those "reasons to be
related soon" comes into account. Where
Bird Box and
Mad Black Wheel were superb horror novels by a creative writer,
Unbury Carol
shows that he can be unlimited in where his imagination takes him and
he can turn what would be a good but conventional idea into something
that aggressively gnaws at your imagination.. The idea of Josh Malerman
let loose in the literature world is most exhilarating and pleasantly
terrifying by itself.